|
Post by kerrygold on Oct 22, 2015 13:49:33 GMT
The time to post the rankings is surely after all the championship and leagues are over on a self centred note 4 division 3 teams are ranked above Beaufort who are division 3 champions Legion are last club standing so it is not too hard to count backwards........................
|
|
1955
Full Member
Posts: 117
|
Post by 1955 on Oct 22, 2015 21:59:03 GMT
So according to these rankings Desmonds and Spa are ranked above St Mary's who they have beaten on their way to the intermediate title
|
|
|
Post by tman59 on Oct 23, 2015 16:43:18 GMT
So according to these rankings Desmonds and Spa are ranked above St Mary's who they have beaten on their way to the intermediate title I would still rank spa and desmonds above Marys, spa got it totally wrong on day and if they have scored even 1 of there 5/6 goal chances they would have bate marys , If Thomas Hickey was fully fit he would have beaten marys on his own!! I wouldn't go straight into saying marys are better teams than them. A lot of things to look at.
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on Oct 23, 2015 16:46:51 GMT
So according to these rankings Desmonds and Spa are ranked above St Mary's who they have beaten on their way to the intermediate title I would still rank spa and desmonds above Marys, spa got it totally wrong on day and if they have scored even 1 of there 5/6 goal chances they would have bate marys , If Thomas Hickey was fully fit he would have beaten marys on his own!! I wouldn't go straight into saying marys are better teams than them. A lot of things to look at. Beaten and nearly never bulled the cow. One sentiment I don't agree with in match analysis is, If all the goal chances were taken.....................They weren't taken because they were missed by someone who wasn't good enough to take them. Simple calculation.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2015 17:18:27 GMT
1 Legion 2 Dr. Crokes 3 Austin Stacks 4 Dingle 5 Kerins O`Rahilly's 6 Rathmore 7 Templenoe 8 Kilcummin 9 Glenbeigh-Glencar 10 St. Mary's 11 Castleisland Desmonds 12 Milltown/Castlemaine 13 Spa 14 John Mitchel's 15 Kenmare 16 Waterville 17 Finuge 18 St Michael's-Foilmore 19 Listowel Emmetts 20 Beaufort 21 Laune Rangers 22 Gneeveguilla 23 An Ghaeltacht 24 Currow 25 Ballydonoghue 26 Glenflesk 27 Annascaul 28 Tarbert 29 Listry 30 Dromid Pearses 31 Firies 32 Keel 33 Ardfert 34 Blennerville 35 Fossa 36 Brosna 37 Lispole 38 Skelligs Rangers 39 Churchill 40 Beale 41 Moyvane 42 Ballymac 43 Na Gaeil 44 Dr.Crokes B 45 Castlegregory 46 Cromane 47 Renard 48 Cordal 49 Valentia 50 Scartaglin
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on Oct 23, 2015 20:18:43 GMT
1 Legion 2 Dr. Crokes 3 Austin Stacks 4 Dingle 5 Kerins O`Rahilly's 6 Rathmore 7 Templenoe 8 Kilcummin 9 Glenbeigh-Glencar 10 St. Mary's 11 Castleisland Desmonds 12 Milltown/Castlemaine 13 Spa 14 John Mitchel's 15 Kenmare 16 Waterville 17 Finuge 18 St Michael's-Foilmore 19 Listowel Emmetts 20 Beaufort 21 Laune Rangers 22 Gneeveguilla 23 An Ghaeltacht 24 Currow 25 Ballydonoghue 26 Glenflesk 27 Annascaul 28 Tarbert 29 Listry 30 Dromid Pearses 31 Firies 32 Keel 33 Ardfert 34 Blennerville 35 Fossa 36 Brosna 37 Lispole 38 Skelligs Rangers 39 Churchill 40 Beale 41 Moyvane 42 Ballymac 43 Na Gaeil 44 Dr.Crokes B 45 Castlegregory 46 Cromane 47 Renard 48 Cordal 49 Valentia 50 Scartaglin Which of the tourist shops in Killarney sell the Crokes tinted glasses? Is the one across from the Tatlers that sells the fishing rods and the touristy memorabilia? Dingle and Rathmore have both beaten Crokes in the championships in recent weeks?
|
|
|
Post by Annascaultilidie on Oct 24, 2015 5:30:59 GMT
Yeah you can't have Legion top and Crokes second, that doesn't really add up.
Why do you have Legion top? If they are for the reasons I think then you can't have Crokes second.
|
|
|
Post by kickitlong on Oct 24, 2015 12:05:02 GMT
Why are scart bottom
|
|
|
Post by leftoutside on Oct 24, 2015 12:54:33 GMT
Tuosist aren't mentioned there either?
|
|
|
Post by frankgalvintralee on Nov 2, 2015 16:06:19 GMT
Updated table by me im going to be honest here? What ye think?
1 - Austin Stacks 2 - Legion 3 - RAHILLYS 4 – dINGLE 5 – Crokes 6 – RATHMORE 7 - DESMONDS 8 – MILTOWN 9 – KILLCUMIN 10 - St.Mary's 11 – Spa 12 – TEMPELNOE 13 - KENMARE 14 - Ardfert 15 – GLENBEIGH 16 - MITCHELS 17 - AN GHAELTACHT 18 - LAUNE RANGERS 19 – WATERVILLE 20 – Listowel 21 - CURROW 22 – Beaufort 23 - Tarbert 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Glenflesk 27 – Brosna 28 - Finuge 29 - Gneeveguilla 30 - keel 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Beale 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Dromid 37 - Ballymac 38 - Churchill 39 - na gaeil 40 - Fires 41 - Lispole 42 – Senans 43 – Scartaglin 44 - Moyvane 45 - Renard 46 - Crokes B 47 - Cordal 48 - Fossa 49 - Castlegregory 50 - Valentia 51 - Cromane 52 - Knock 53 - Asdee 54 - Sneem/Derrynane 55 - Duagh 56 - Ballyduff 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B
|
|
rapook
Junior Member
Posts: 48
|
Post by rapook on Nov 2, 2015 21:14:56 GMT
listry 31st hmmmm
ardfert 7 pts behind listry in league yet 17 places ahead. brosna 6 behind and hammered by listry in league yet 4 places ahead annuscaul behind listry in league yet 6 places ahead gaelteacht level with listry in league and beat by listry in same yet 14 places ahead keel 5 pts behind listry in league yet ahead in your rankings
finuge sure bottom of 1 but 29th really
|
|
Jigz84
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,017
|
Post by Jigz84 on Nov 27, 2015 13:40:23 GMT
Dingle, Senior Club Champions, No. 1
|
|
Premier
Fanatical Member
Posts: 1,243
|
Post by Premier on Nov 27, 2015 16:09:23 GMT
Dingle, Senior Club Champions, No. 1 Ha
|
|
|
Post by greengold35 on Nov 27, 2015 17:31:26 GMT
listry 31st hmmmm ardfert 7 pts behind listry in league yet 17 places ahead. brosna 6 behind and hammered by listry in league yet 4 places ahead annuscaul behind listry in league yet 6 places ahead gaelteacht level with listry in league and beat by listry in same yet 14 places ahead keel 5 pts behind listry in league yet ahead in your rankings finuge sure bottom of 1 but 29th really Ardfert ( senior) and all the other clubs played at intermediate with Listry plying their trade at junior level- this has to be taken into account too; Listry going up to Div 2 after relegation last year is a plus but on the other hand they were beaten at the semi final stage of the championship, supplied only 3 players to the EK divisional team, 1 player to the EK U-21 team and were beaten last week end by Scartaglin who were ranked 10+ places below them. Ranking accurate enough imo.
|
|
1479
Full Member
Posts: 241
|
Post by 1479 on Nov 28, 2015 10:43:01 GMT
listry 31st hmmmm ardfert 7 pts behind listry in league yet 17 places ahead. brosna 6 behind and hammered by listry in league yet 4 places ahead annuscaul behind listry in league yet 6 places ahead gaelteacht level with listry in league and beat by listry in same yet 14 places ahead keel 5 pts behind listry in league yet ahead in your rankings finuge sure bottom of 1 but 29th really Ardfert ( senior) and all the other clubs played at intermediate with Listry plying their trade at junior level- this has to be taken into account too; Listry going up to Div 2 after relegation last year is a plus but on the other hand they were beaten at the semi final stage of the championship, supplied only 3 players to the EK divisional team, 1 player to the EK U-21 team and were beaten last week end by Scartaglin who were ranked 10+ places below them. Ranking accurate enough imo. To be fair its a great achievement for a small club like Listry to gain promotion back to division 2. After three or four games the chances of promotion were bleak but showed great character to get important results. Remember their catchment area for players wouldn't be the biggest. They had four players on the EK panel but due to injury only 3 played against KOR. Also had two players winning all-ireland medals this year with Gary O'Sullivan winning with the juniors and Ronan Buckley part of the minor panel. Although their run in the junior championship was shorter than they expected, most teams after winning a novice championship take a year or two to adjust to higher level.
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on Nov 28, 2015 16:58:14 GMT
Ardfert ( senior) and all the other clubs played at intermediate with Listry plying their trade at junior level- this has to be taken into account too; Listry going up to Div 2 after relegation last year is a plus but on the other hand they were beaten at the semi final stage of the championship, supplied only 3 players to the EK divisional team, 1 player to the EK U-21 team and were beaten last week end by Scartaglin who were ranked 10+ places below them. Ranking accurate enough imo. To be fair its a great achievement for a small club like Listry to gain promotion back to division 2. After three or four games the chances of promotion were bleak but showed great character to get important results. Remember their catchment area for players wouldn't be the biggest. They had four players on the EK panel but due to injury only 3 played against KOR. Also had two players winning all-ireland medals this year with Gary O'Sullivan winning with the juniors and Ronan Buckley part of the minor panel. Although their run in the junior championship was shorter than they expected, most teams after winning a novice championship take a year or two to adjust to higher level. It will be an absolute shame, and misguided,if the Suits above in Dublin take away the junior intercounty All -Ireland competition.
|
|
mossie
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,654
|
Post by mossie on Nov 29, 2015 13:53:02 GMT
Ardfert ( senior) and all the other clubs played at intermediate with Listry plying their trade at junior level- this has to be taken into account too; Listry going up to Div 2 after relegation last year is a plus but on the other hand they were beaten at the semi final stage of the championship, supplied only 3 players to the EK divisional team, 1 player to the EK U-21 team and were beaten last week end by Scartaglin who were ranked 10+ places below them. Ranking accurate enough imo. To be fair its a great achievement for a small club like Listry to gain promotion back to division 2. After three or four games the chances of promotion were bleak but showed great character to get important results. Remember their catchment area for players wouldn't be the biggest. They had four players on the EK panel but due to injury only 3 played against KOR. Also had two players winning all-ireland medals this year with Gary O'Sullivan winning with the juniors and Ronan Buckley part of the minor panel. Although their run in the junior championship was shorter than they expected, most teams after winning a novice championship take a year or two to adjust to higher level. Spot on re Listry. They have done remarkably well
|
|
mossie
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,654
|
Post by mossie on Nov 29, 2015 13:57:57 GMT
In any club rankings dual clubs deserve special mention. St Brendans\Ardfert, Lixnaw\Finuge are unreal the way they soldier on in hurling and football. If you are ranking GAA clubs, they are my top two. Football clubs obviously they down the list
|
|
seamo
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,016
|
Post by seamo on Nov 29, 2015 14:08:41 GMT
I think we have lost sight of the criteria/purpose of these rankings. The rankings were meant to be based simply on who is better than who on the field of play. Populations, dual club etc. should have no bearing on these rankings.
No questioning the achievement of clubs like Listry, Finuge, Duagh etc. over the past few years. In terms of resources/ players available they outperform many of the "bigger" clubs. But that's not what these rankings are supposed to be about. Performances in league and championships nothing else.
|
|
|
Post by actionman on Nov 29, 2015 19:58:02 GMT
To be fair its a great achievement for a small club like Listry to gain promotion back to division 2. After three or four games the chances of promotion were bleak but showed great character to get important results. Remember their catchment area for players wouldn't be the biggest. They had four players on the EK panel but due to injury only 3 played against KOR. Also had two players winning all-ireland medals this year with Gary O'Sullivan winning with the juniors and Ronan Buckley part of the minor panel. Although their run in the junior championship was shorter than they expected, most teams after winning a novice championship take a year or two to adjust to higher level. Spot on re Listry. They have done remarkably well Even thou the junior is a bit harder next year I still think Listry have a great chance of wining it, they were narrowly beaten by Templenoe in the novice final two years ago and look how Templenoe have moved on since. Onwards and upwards Listry abu.
|
|