Premier
Fanatical Member
Posts: 1,174
|
Post by Premier on Apr 27, 2015 18:34:48 GMT
It could probably be worked out based on: current county league position ( e.g Crokes get 58, Tousist get 1) Years since win in divisional championship (minus 1 for each year) Years since win in respective Casteisland Mart championship ( minus 1 for each year, max minus 30) 5 points for player who played in last years senior team Total divisional championships Total CastleIsland Mart championships 15 points for Senior 10 points for intermediate, 8 for junior 3 for novice 3 points for each player who played minor or Junior last year 3 points for each player to play u21 this year By this method of ranking the South Kerry clubs would rank as: Mary's 71 Bally/Filmore 59 Waterville 42 Valentia 5 Portmagee -2 Dromid -8 Renard -10 Sneem -20 Derrynane -49 Before anyone reacts to Valentia's high ranking, they have a steep history down South
|
|
Premier
Fanatical Member
Posts: 1,174
|
Post by Premier on Apr 29, 2015 14:44:49 GMT
It could probably be worked out based on: current county league position ( e.g Crokes get 58, Tousist get 1) Years since win in divisional championship (minus 1 for each year) Years since win in respective Casteisland Mart championship ( minus 1 for each year, max minus 30) 5 points for player who played in last years senior team Total divisional championships Total CastleIsland Mart championships 3 points for each player who played minor or Junior last year 3 points for each player to play u21 this year If anyone has any ideas on how to improve this throw them out there, I came up with this in 5 mins so I'm sure there could be something added to it
|
|
|
Post by Mickmack on Apr 29, 2015 15:47:57 GMT
If you are basing things on being the best they can be given their circumstances and "circumstances" would be things like population, whether the players also play hurling, competing with other sports in the locality then you would be looking at a top 5 as follows;
1.. Finuge 2...Ardfert 3...st Michael Foilmore 4.... Kilcummin (didn't they win the minor a few years ago!!! 5... Brosna 6...Crokes 7... Stacks 8... Dingle (mainly due to the work at underage level) 9....An Gaeltackt.... ditto as for Dingle 10... Tuosist.... for fielding a team even though they lost their best player 11... Legion 12.... KOR
Bottom of the pile would be Listowel with St Marys Caherciveen and Castleisland down there too as they are town teams with a decent pick to choose from
|
|
|
Post by Annascaultilidie on Apr 29, 2015 15:53:09 GMT
Bottom of the pile would be Listowel with St Marys Caherciveen and Castleisland down there too as they are town teams with a decent pick to choose from Listowel would have a far greater population than these but Dingle is bigger than Caherciveen and not far off Castleisland.
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on Apr 29, 2015 16:40:13 GMT
There is no huge population around Caherciveen!
|
|
Premier
Fanatical Member
Posts: 1,174
|
Post by Premier on Apr 29, 2015 18:17:50 GMT
If you are basing things on being the best they can be given their circumstances and "circumstances" would be things like population, whether the players also play hurling, competing with other sports in the locality then you would be looking at a top 5 as follows; 1.. Finuge 2...Ardfert 3...st Michael Foilmore 4.... Kilcummin (didn't they win the minor a few years ago!!! 5... Brosna 6...Crokes 7... Stacks 8... Dingle (mainly due to the work at underage level) 9....An Gaeltackt.... ditto as for Dingle 10... Tuosist.... for fielding a team even though they lost their best player 11... Legion 12.... KOR Bottom of the pile would be Listowel with St Marys Caherciveen and Castleisland down there too as they are town teams with a decent pick to choose from Definetly wouldn't consider the Mary's as under achieves . 30 SK championships speaks for itself. Also Waterville have only a 4 teacher school to base off and have been in division 1 for 3 years and don't think have ever dropped down to Junior status, as well as competing in 3 county finals around the 1970s
|
|
|
Post by walker07 on May 12, 2015 11:22:53 GMT
Would stacks be number 1 now after wining division 1
|
|
|
Post by tman59 on May 13, 2015 13:07:43 GMT
MY UPDATE
1 - Dr Crokes 2 - Austin Stacks 3 - Kerins O Rahillys 4 - Legion 5 - Dingle 6 - Milltown 7 - Rathmore 8 - Desmonds 9 - Kilcummin 10 - Glenbeigh 11 - Waterville 12 - Spa 13 - John Mithells 14 - Finuge 15 - Ardfert 16 - St Michaels Foilmore 17 - Listowel 18 - St. Marys 19 - Kenmare 20 - Launge Rangers 21 - Templenoe 22 - Glenflesk 23 - Annascaul 24 - Currow 25 - Tarbert 26 - Beaufort 27 - Keel 28 - An Gaeltacht 29 - Brosna 30 - Gneeveguilla 31 - St Patrick's Blennerville 32 - Skelligs Rangers G.A.A. Club 33 - Na Gaeil 34 - Castlegregory GAA Club 35 - Firies GAA 36 - Listry 37 - Ballydonoghue 38 - Dromid Pearses 39 - Ballymacelligott 40 - Beale 41 - Cordal GAA Club 42 - Fossa 43 - Churchill 44 - Lispole 45 - Scartaglin 46 - Dr.Crokes B 47 - Cromane 48 - Valentia/Dairbhre 49 - Moyvane 50 - St Senan's 51 - Sneem/Derrynane 52 - Duagh 53 - Renard 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Ballyduff 56 - Austin Stacks B 57 - Asdee 58 - Ballylongford 59 - Tuosist
|
|
|
Post by frankgalvintralee on May 20, 2015 23:51:30 GMT
MY UPDATE 1 - Dr Crokes 2 - Austin Stacks 3 - Kerins O Rahillys 4 - Legion 5 - Dingle 6 - Milltown 7 - Rathmore 8 - Desmonds 9 - Kilcummin 10 - Glenbeigh 11 - Waterville 12 - Spa 13 - John Mithells 14 - Finuge 15 - Ardfert 16 - St Michaels Foilmore 17 - Listowel 18 - St. Marys 19 - Kenmare 20 - Launge Rangers 21 - Templenoe 22 - Glenflesk 23 - Annascaul 24 - Currow 25 - Tarbert 26 - Beaufort 27 - Keel 28 - An Gaeltacht 29 - Brosna 30 - Gneeveguilla 31 - St Patrick's Blennerville 32 - Skelligs Rangers G.A.A. Club 33 - Na Gaeil 34 - Castlegregory GAA Club 35 - Firies GAA 36 - Listry 37 - Ballydonoghue 38 - Dromid Pearses 39 - Ballymacelligott 40 - Beale 41 - Cordal GAA Club 42 - Fossa 43 - Churchill 44 - Lispole 45 - Scartaglin 46 - Dr.Crokes B 47 - Cromane 48 - Valentia/Dairbhre 49 - Moyvane 50 - St Senan's 51 - Sneem/Derrynane 52 - Duagh 53 - Renard 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Ballyduff 56 - Austin Stacks B 57 - Asdee 58 - Ballylongford 59 - Tuosist Very bad knowledge in them rankings !
|
|
|
Post by tman59 on May 21, 2015 23:03:01 GMT
MY UPDATE 1 - Dr Crokes 2 - Austin Stacks 3 - Kerins O Rahillys 4 - Legion 5 - Dingle 6 - Milltown 7 - Rathmore 8 - Desmonds 9 - Kilcummin 10 - Glenbeigh 11 - Waterville 12 - Spa 13 - John Mithells 14 - Finuge 15 - Ardfert 16 - St Michaels Foilmore 17 - Listowel 18 - St. Marys 19 - Kenmare 20 - Launge Rangers 21 - Templenoe 22 - Glenflesk 23 - Annascaul 24 - Currow 25 - Tarbert 26 - Beaufort 27 - Keel 28 - An Gaeltacht 29 - Brosna 30 - Gneeveguilla 31 - St Patrick's Blennerville 32 - Skelligs Rangers G.A.A. Club 33 - Na Gaeil 34 - Castlegregory GAA Club 35 - Firies GAA 36 - Listry 37 - Ballydonoghue 38 - Dromid Pearses 39 - Ballymacelligott 40 - Beale 41 - Cordal GAA Club 42 - Fossa 43 - Churchill 44 - Lispole 45 - Scartaglin 46 - Dr.Crokes B 47 - Cromane 48 - Valentia/Dairbhre 49 - Moyvane 50 - St Senan's 51 - Sneem/Derrynane 52 - Duagh 53 - Renard 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Ballyduff 56 - Austin Stacks B 57 - Asdee 58 - Ballylongford 59 - Tuosist Very bad knowledge in them rankings ! You give it a go
|
|
|
Post by Annascaultilidie on May 21, 2015 23:27:55 GMT
How come people rank legion ahead of rathmore when Rathmore beat them last yr in east Kerry champ and have been around the block a lot longer. Also don't think mill town should be higher than rathmore.rathmore in division 2 I know and missing a few players for rest of season but they would still beat them two teams and have done on a regular basis Up until Stacks got their house in order I would have had Rathmore as number TWO over the last five years.
|
|
|
Post by frankgalvintralee on May 22, 2015 17:47:14 GMT
Very bad knowledge in them rankings ! You give it a go I am picking mine not on clubs standings in County League or if you are Senior or Junior or whatever im picking mine on teams football ability and how clubs are doing at the present time in Club Championships District Leagues County League and last year that is all 1 - Austin Stacks 2 - Crokes 3 - RAHILLYS 4 – dINGLE 5 – Rathmore 6 – Legion 7 - DESMONDS 8 – MILTOWN 9 – KILLCUMIN 10 - ARDFERT 11 – STMARYS 12 – TEMPELNOE 13 - KENMARE 14 - SPA 15 – GLENBEIGH 16 - MITCHELS 17 - AN GHAELTACHT 18 - LAUNE RANGERS 19 – WATERVILLE 20 – Listowel 21 - CURROW 22 – Finuge 23 - Tarbert 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Glenflesk 27 – Brosna 28 - Beaufort 29 - Gneeveguilla 30 - keel 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Fires 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Castle 37 - Ballymac 38 - Churchill 39 - na gaeil 40 - Baele 41 - Lispole 42 – Crokes B 43 – Senans 44 - Renard 45 - Fossa 46 - Dromid 47 - Cordal 48 - Moyvane 49 - Scataglin 50 - Duagh 51 - Cromane 52 - Knock 53 - Asdee 54 - Sneem/Derrynane 55 - Valentia 56 - Ballyduff 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B Read more: kerrygaa.proboards.com/thread/5719/club-rankings?page=1#ixzz3atHMwIcH
|
|
Premier
Fanatical Member
Posts: 1,174
|
Post by Premier on May 23, 2015 8:28:54 GMT
I am picking mine not on clubs standings in County League or if you are Senior or Junior or whatever im picking mine on teams football ability and how clubs are doing at the present time in Club Championships District Leagues County League and last year that is all 1 - Austin Stacks 2 - Crokes 3 - RAHILLYS 4 – dINGLE 5 – Rathmore 6 – Legion 7 - DESMONDS 8 – MILTOWN 9 – KILLCUMIN 10 - ARDFERT 11 – STMARYS 12 – TEMPELNOE 13 - KENMARE 14 - SPA 15 – GLENBEIGH 16 - MITCHELS 17 - AN GHAELTACHT 18 - LAUNE RANGERS 19 – WATERVILLE 20 – Listowel 21 - CURROW 22 – Finuge 23 - Tarbert 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Glenflesk 27 – Brosna 28 - Beaufort 29 - Gneeveguilla 30 - keel 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Fires 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Castle 37 - Ballymac 38 - Churchill 39 - na gaeil 40 - Baele 41 - Lispole 42 – Crokes B 43 – Senans 44 - Renard 45 - Fossa 46 - Dromid 47 - Cordal 48 - Moyvane 49 - Scataglin 50 - Duagh 51 - Cromane 52 - Knock 53 - Asdee 54 - Sneem/Derrynane 55 - Valentia 56 - Ballyduff 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B Read more: kerrygaa.proboards.com/thread/5719/club-rankings?page=1#ixzz3atHMwIcHGaeltacht seem very high in that they haven't won a West Kerry championship in a good few years, nearly got relegated to division 4 last year and got knocked out in round 2 of the Intermediate this year
|
|
|
Post by kerrybhoy06 on May 23, 2015 8:56:55 GMT
I just want to say that if Rahillys are the number 3 club in Kerry then no amount of restructuring of the county championship will lead to it being more competitive. They are miles off Crokes and would prob lose by 10+ points to them
|
|
|
Post by greengold35 on May 23, 2015 10:32:42 GMT
I just want to say that if Rahillys are the number 3 club in Kerry then no amount of restructuring of the county championship will lead to it being more competitive. They are miles off Crokes and would prob lose by 10+ points to them That's a possibility but Crokes winning margins over Legion & Rathmore were only 4 points- Legion had a point to spare over Strand Rd in a game that could easily have gone the other way; likewise Crokes looked like they were going to blitz Rathmore last week end but ended up winning by 4 when they had a 12 point lead at half time- the wind was a major factor here though. There is not much between any of these sides on their day but would definitely have Crokes & Stacks as the top 2 currently.
|
|
hugh20
Senior Member
Posts: 734
|
Post by hugh20 on May 28, 2015 11:47:03 GMT
1 - Dr. Crokes 2 - Stacks 3 - Rathmore 4 – Legion 5 – Dingle 6 – Rahillys 7 - Milltown/Castle 8 – Desmonds 9 – Kilcummin 10 - Spa 11 – St Marys 12 – Ardfert 13 - Kenmare 14 - John Mitchels 15 – Glenbeigh 16 - Waterville 17 - Laune Rangers 18 - Templenoe 19 – Finuge 20 – Listowel 21 - Glenflesk 22 – Currow 23 - An Ghaeltacht 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Tarbert 27 – Gneevguilla 28 - Brosna 29 - Keel 30 - Beaufort 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Castlegregory 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Ballymac 37 - Firies 38 - Na Gaeil 39 - Beale 40 - Lispole 41 - Dr Crokes B 42 – Cordal 43 – Fossa 44 - Churchill 45 - Senans 46 - Dromid 47 - Renard 48 - Duagh 49 - Scartaglin 50 - Cromane 51 - Moyvane 52 - Valentia 53 - Ballyduff 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Asdee 56 - Sneem/Derrynane 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B
On "current form", then Stacks could not possibly top the rankings, losing comprehensively to Dingle and narrowly overcoming Michaels/Foilmore who would be short odds to get relegated.
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on May 28, 2015 16:35:50 GMT
1 - Dr. Crokes 2 - Stacks 3 - Rathmore 4 – Legion 5 – Dingle 6 – Rahillys 7 - Milltown/Castle 8 – Desmonds 9 – Kilcummin 10 - Spa 11 – St Marys 12 – Ardfert 13 - Kenmare 14 - John Mitchels 15 – Glenbeigh 16 - Waterville 17 - Laune Rangers 18 - Templenoe 19 – Finuge 20 – Listowel 21 - Glenflesk 22 – Currow 23 - An Ghaeltacht 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Tarbert 27 – Gneevguilla 28 - Brosna 29 - Keel 30 - Beaufort 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Castlegregory 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Ballymac 37 - Firies 38 - Na Gaeil 39 - Beale 40 - Lispole 41 - Dr Crokes B 42 – Cordal 43 – Fossa 44 - Churchill 45 - Senans 46 - Dromid 47 - Renard 48 - Duagh 49 - Scartaglin 50 - Cromane 51 - Moyvane 52 - Valentia 53 - Ballyduff 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Asdee 56 - Sneem/Derrynane 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B On "current form", then Stacks could not possibly top the rankings, losing comprehensively to Dingle and narrowly overcoming Michaels/Foilmore who would be short odds to get relegated. Crokes have done nothing to merit number one status in Kerry just yet in 2015. Stacks are double league and Championship winners "currently"
|
|
hugh20
Senior Member
Posts: 734
|
Post by hugh20 on May 28, 2015 20:13:02 GMT
My rankings are based on the belief that if all of these teams had full teams I believe they are better than those teams that are ranked below them. Austin Stacks won 2014, we are now in 2015 and I'm not having this pointless argument all over again. U believe Stacks should be number one and I believe Crokes should be, it always be an opinion and never a proven fact.
|
|
|
Post by Mickmack on May 28, 2015 20:26:55 GMT
Stick to your guns Hugh if thats what you believe. How is Colm playing?
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on May 28, 2015 20:34:20 GMT
My rankings are based on the belief that if all of these teams had full teams I believe they are better than those teams that are ranked below them. Austin Stacks won 2014, we are now in 2015 and I'm not having this pointless argument all over again. U believe Stacks should be number one and I believe Crokes should be, it always be an opinion and never a proven fact. I don't believe anyone should be number one until the championship is won. All else is heresay.
|
|
seamo
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,016
|
Post by seamo on May 28, 2015 21:32:49 GMT
My rankings are based on the belief that if all of these teams had full teams I believe they are better than those teams that are ranked below them. Austin Stacks won 2014, we are now in 2015 and I'm not having this pointless argument all over again. U believe Stacks should be number one and I believe Crokes should be, it always be an opinion and never a proven fact. ah come off it man!Very sly. You waited until Stacks had some less than satisfactory performances to post these rankings; or are you going to be posting your rankings every week/2 weeks? How long ago is it since Crokes actually beat Stacks in a senior club game? lol
|
|
seamo
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,016
|
Post by seamo on May 28, 2015 21:35:23 GMT
My rankings are based on the belief that if all of these teams had full teams I believe they are better than those teams that are ranked below them. Austin Stacks won 2014, we are now in 2015 and I'm not having this pointless argument all over again. U believe Stacks should be number one and I believe Crokes should be, it always be an opinion and never a proven fact. If that's your criteria than quit now! Seriously have you considered every injury in every club when you did these rankings, and every case of emigration? Or did you just consider those which effect Crokes!! lol
|
|
hugh20
Senior Member
Posts: 734
|
Post by hugh20 on May 28, 2015 22:19:52 GMT
My rankings are based on the belief that if all of these teams had full teams I believe they are better than those teams that are ranked below them. Austin Stacks won 2014, we are now in 2015 and I'm not having this pointless argument all over again. U believe Stacks should be number one and I believe Crokes should be, it always be an opinion and never a proven fact. ah come off it man!Very sly. You waited until Stacks had some less than satisfactory performances to post these rankings; or are you going to be posting your rankings every week/2 weeks? How long ago is it since Crokes actually beat Stacks in a senior club game? lol i think if you go back through all my posts You will find I have said Numerous times that I believed that Crokes were a better team. I did not wait until Stacks had sub standard performances, I am not naive enough to write off Stacks especially when they are missing crucial players like they are at the moment. If you disagree with my post that's fair enough your own opinion but I did genuinely do a lot of thinking when picking the rankings and I believe they are fair enough. Of course teams are rarely going to have full strength team and of course I didn't factor in emigration. How could I factor in emigration, these players are more than likely gone for good and unfortunately not coming home. Am I supposed to put my rankings with Beaufort up in the top 5 if they had Dan Doona and Damien Breen?? I think you took my "full teams" comment out of context!! The last time Crokes beat Stacks I think it was the 2013 County final, although they have not played a whole pile of games since then.
|
|
hugh20
Senior Member
Posts: 734
|
Post by hugh20 on May 28, 2015 22:25:19 GMT
Stick to your guns Hugh if thats what you believe. How is Colm playing? Colm is doing well enough, his knee seems to be overcoming the training and matches anyway. I think getting through these is probably the priority for the moment and performances will follow. He had a quiet game for his own standards against Shannon Rangers and likewise against Rathmore but once his confidence builds up with more games he will come more into his own then. I haven't seen the sharp jink that we were so used to but that will hopefully come back with time also.
|
|
seamo
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,016
|
Post by seamo on Jun 1, 2015 9:31:56 GMT
ah come off it man!Very sly. You waited until Stacks had some less than satisfactory performances to post these rankings; or are you going to be posting your rankings every week/2 weeks? How long ago is it since Crokes actually beat Stacks in a senior club game? lol i think if you go back through all my posts You will find I have said Numerous times that I believed that Crokes were a better team. I did not wait until Stacks had sub standard performances, I am not naive enough to write off Stacks especially when they are missing crucial players like they are at the moment. If you disagree with my post that's fair enough your own opinion but I did genuinely do a lot of thinking when picking the rankings and I believe they are fair enough. Of course teams are rarely going to have full strength team and of course I didn't factor in emigration. How could I factor in emigration, these players are more than likely gone for good and unfortunately not coming home. Am I supposed to put my rankings with Beaufort up in the top 5 if they had Dan Doona and Damien Breen?? I think you took my "full teams" comment out of context!! The last time Crokes beat Stacks I think it was the 2013 County final, although they have not played a whole pile of games since then. lol If anything I put it into the context of is usually said by Dr.Crokes. Maybe you were 100% against it at the time but I can still remember someone from Croke's bemoaning how they've been hit so hard by emigration! Front of the Kerryman/Kerry's Eye ~3 years ago, funny stuff . My point really is the "rankings based on full teams" is bs, and is an angle used to dismiss Stacks achievements last year. Not saying this is your view, but Colm's injury is used a an excuse for Stacks succeeding last year.
|
|
hugh20
Senior Member
Posts: 734
|
Post by hugh20 on Jun 2, 2015 11:28:03 GMT
i think if you go back through all my posts You will find I have said Numerous times that I believed that Crokes were a better team. I did not wait until Stacks had sub standard performances, I am not naive enough to write off Stacks especially when they are missing crucial players like they are at the moment. If you disagree with my post that's fair enough your own opinion but I did genuinely do a lot of thinking when picking the rankings and I believe they are fair enough. Of course teams are rarely going to have full strength team and of course I didn't factor in emigration. How could I factor in emigration, these players are more than likely gone for good and unfortunately not coming home. Am I supposed to put my rankings with Beaufort up in the top 5 if they had Dan Doona and Damien Breen?? I think you took my "full teams" comment out of context!! The last time Crokes beat Stacks I think it was the 2013 County final, although they have not played a whole pile of games since then. lol If anything I put it into the context of is usually said by Dr.Crokes. Maybe you were 100% against it at the time but I can still remember someone from Croke's bemoaning how they've been hit so hard by emigration! Front of the Kerryman/Kerry's Eye ~3 years ago, funny stuff . My point really is the "rankings based on full teams" is bs, and is an angle used to dismiss Stacks achievements last year. Not saying this is your view, but Colm's injury is used a an excuse for Stacks succeeding last year. I don't agree that Crokes have been hit with emigration hard at all, certainly not in comparison to the rural clubs in particular who have been crippled. Crokes should be able to cope with players emigrating anyway being a town club and given the pick. I could only name a handful of players who have left and most have returned like Eanna Kavanagh, Shane Doolan, Alan Kelly and Michael Moloney. I wasn't looking for an angle to dismiss Stacks achievements last year. They fully deserved to win the county and Munster last year and I genuinely supported them when they went on to represent Kerry, and they were extremely unfortunate not to get to Croker which proved their capabilities. The club rankings, I thought, was to pick who you thought to be the best sides in order and that is what I have done.
|
|
|
Post by kicktheballinlowhi on Oct 20, 2015 22:28:37 GMT
Looking at the Club Championship and clubs in general in Kerry how would you rank them and how do you think the standard in Kerry is right now . I will go from one to ten in Kerry and I would like to hear some opinions and who ye think is the best . 1 . Dr.Crokes ( Not being biased but on their day they are hard to beat . I think they have the best club players in the County ). 2. Austin Stacks ( They are County Champions but the reason they are not number one is they rely too much on Donaghy . You could say that about Crokes too with Cooper but I think Crokes have a better balance and better Forwards). 3. Legion ( A lot of talent and could possibly have 5 on the Kerry panel this year . Jamie O'Sulivan is a good addition to them and they are getting better every year ). 4. Kerins O' Rahilly's ( Have great potential and when they have a full team are tough to beat . Probably need a couple of backs to go to the next level ). 5. Dingle ( The up and comers !! I don't know what's in the water back west but Dingle have some serious young talent coming up . If they can keep them around and they stay injury free they should win a lot of Trophies and will be ranked number 1 down the road ). 6. Rathmore ( This is where it gets tricky . For me Rathmore rank in here because despite being in Division 2 they are a solid team and are too good for that Division . They always produce good players and would give any club in Kerry a close game ) . 7. Milltown/Castlemaine ( Amazing club really because they don't have a very big pick but are just solid and consistently get the results needed to stay in Division one every year ). 8. Kilcummin ( Not as good as other years and took a hit losing Jamie O'Sullivan and others but Kilcummin are still a handful for any team in the County and they have that never say die attitude ). 9. St.Mary's ( I don't understand this team . Can be really good and then the next week can be terrible . If they could get some level of consistency they would be in Division 1 ). 10. Templenoe ( I think they will be in Division 1 in the next 2 years if they keep their players around ) . So that's my 10 . Of course I left out teams like Desmonds , Mitchels , Spa , Waterville etc but I don't rate them that highly . There is not a lot between the Divisions with most team having the ability to beat each other . Ardfert in Division 3 could beat Finuge in Division 1 . So it is hard to judge it . Let's see some top tens . Good rankings. I'd put Dingle ahead of Rahilly's but there isn't much in it. Don't think Mary's deserve to be there, flatter to deceive too often, and Templenoe need to deliver more before being top-10. I would have Foilmore and Ardfert as my 9 and 10. St. Marys flatter to deceive? Think their last 2 championship games surely changes your mind about that
|
|
|
Post by kerrygold on Oct 21, 2015 8:28:11 GMT
1 - Dr. Crokes 2 - Stacks 3 - Rathmore 4 – Legion 5 – Dingle 6 – Rahillys 7 - Milltown/Castle 8 – Desmonds 9 – Kilcummin 10 - Spa 11 – St Marys 12 – Ardfert 13 - Kenmare 14 - John Mitchels 15 – Glenbeigh 16 - Waterville 17 - Laune Rangers 18 - Templenoe 19 – Finuge 20 – Listowel 21 - Glenflesk 22 – Currow 23 - An Ghaeltacht 24 – St Michaels/Foilmore 25 – Annascaul 26 - Tarbert 27 – Gneevguilla 28 - Brosna 29 - Keel 30 - Beaufort 31 - Listry 32 - Skellig Rangers 33 – Castlegregory 34 - Ballydonoghue 35 - St.Pats 36 - Ballymac 37 - Firies 38 - Na Gaeil 39 - Beale 40 - Lispole 41 - Dr Crokes B 42 – Cordal 43 – Fossa 44 - Churchill 45 - Senans 46 - Dromid 47 - Renard 48 - Duagh 49 - Scartaglin 50 - Cromane 51 - Moyvane 52 - Valentia 53 - Ballyduff 54 - Knocknagoshel 55 - Asdee 56 - Sneem/Derrynane 57 - Tousist 58 - Ballylongford 59 – Austin Stacks B On "current form", then Stacks could not possibly top the rankings, losing comprehensively to Dingle and narrowly overcoming Michaels/Foilmore who would be short odds to get relegated. Crokes have done nothing to merit number one status in Kerry just yet in 2015. Stacks are double league and Championship winners "currently" This needs to be reviewed now? Probable, 1. Legion 2. Rathmore 3. Dingle 4. Crokes 5. Stacks
|
|
|
Post by kickitlong on Oct 21, 2015 9:36:42 GMT
The time to post the rankings is surely after all the championship and leagues are over on a self centred note 4 division 3 teams are ranked above Beaufort who are division 3 champions
|
|
|
Post by actionman on Oct 21, 2015 13:07:13 GMT
The time to post the rankings is surely after all the championship and leagues are over on a self centred note 4 division 3 teams are ranked above Beaufort who are division 3 champions Listry 2nd in div 3 so ya surley will have to be moved up a few slots
|
|