Jo90
Fanatical Member
Posts: 2,566
|
Post by Jo90 on Dec 13, 2019 13:39:51 GMT
A Kerry one and a national one
Kerry:
Kelly
M Ó Sé O'Mahony Enright
Murphy Crowley Morley
Moran Maher
O'Donoghue Gooch D Walsh
Clifford Donaghy P Geaney
National:
Cluxton
Cooper McGee Higgins
McAffrey McCarthy Keegan
Moran Fenton
Flynn Murphy Kilkenny
BBrogan McManus Moran
|
|
|
|
Post by themanfromthewest on Dec 13, 2019 14:26:17 GMT
Would agree with your Kerry team, only change I’d make on your national team would be to switch Karl Lacey for Cooper at no. 2
Only other Kerry player that would be close is Geaney imo. Kerry have had a solid team throughout the decade but hard to argue that you could displace any of the above. Hopefully the team of the 20’s will be peppered in green and gold.
|
|
|
|
Post by kerrybhoy06 on Dec 13, 2019 14:45:17 GMT
Cluxton
McGlynn
Cooper (despite the absolute roasting he got this year)
Lacey
McCaffrey
McCarthy
Keegan
Fenton
Moran
Flynn
Aidan O Shea
Kilkenny
B Brogan
Murphy
Geaney
The last position was between Geaney & McManus and was prob the hardest to pick but Geaney had a huge impact on the final in 2014 and was excellent the first day out this year so he has had more of an influence in the bigger games.
I know you could argue that McManus hasnt gotten the chance to influence finals but then you are opening up a whole diff can of worms as the same could be argued for loads of players.
Only other Kerry players in contention would be Marc and Gooch but they were done by 2014.
Honourable mentions to Cian O Sullivan, Colm McFadden, Colm Cavangh, Diarmuid O Connor, Paddy Durkin, Ryan McHugh, Andy Moran and a real personal favourite of mine in Jamie Clarke.
Player of the decade for me would be between Bernard Brogan & Cluxton and I guess that you would have to give it to Cluxton
|
|
|
|
Post by Whosinmidfield on Dec 13, 2019 15:49:31 GMT
Cluxton
Cooper NMcGee Higgins
McCaffrey Lacey Keegan
Fenton McCarthy
Kilkenny Murphy Flynn
McManus Geaney Brogan
|
|
|
|
Post by skybluezone on Dec 13, 2019 16:36:55 GMT
Cluxton McGlynn Cooper (despite the absolute roasting he got this year) Lacey McCaffrey McCarthy Keegan Fenton Moran Flynn Aidan O Shea Kilkenny B Brogan Murphy Geaney The last position was between Geaney & McManus and was prob the hardest to pick but Geaney had a huge impact on the final in 2014 and was excellent the first day out this year so he has had more of an influence in the bigger games. I know you could argue that McManus hasnt gotten the chance to influence finals but then you are opening up a whole diff can of worms as the same could be argued for loads of players. Only other Kerry players in contention would be Marc and Gooch but they were done by 2014. Honourable mentions to Cian O Sullivan, Colm McFadden, Colm Cavangh, Diarmuid O Connor, Paddy Durkin, Ryan McHugh, Andy Moran and a real personal favourite of mine in Jamie Clarke. Player of the decade for me would be between Bernard Brogan & Cluxton and I guess that you would have to give it to Cluxton Rory O'Carroll did enough pre 2016 to get full back. Dont think anyone else 2016 onwards dominated fb spot. McManus close to best forward in Ireland has to get in to ff line. If as you say big perfomances in big games are a factor then Philly must be close, possibly for McGlynn. For the same reason Aidan o'Shea drops out. Agree with your honourable mentions. Would add DC and Rock to that list. |
|
|
|
Post by kerrybhoy06 on Dec 13, 2019 16:48:09 GMT
Cluxton McGlynn Cooper (despite the absolute roasting he got this year) Lacey McCaffrey McCarthy Keegan Fenton Moran Flynn Aidan O Shea Kilkenny B Brogan Murphy Geaney The last position was between Geaney & McManus and was prob the hardest to pick but Geaney had a huge impact on the final in 2014 and was excellent the first day out this year so he has had more of an influence in the bigger games. I know you could argue that McManus hasnt gotten the chance to influence finals but then you are opening up a whole diff can of worms as the same could be argued for loads of players. Only other Kerry players in contention would be Marc and Gooch but they were done by 2014. Honourable mentions to Cian O Sullivan, Colm McFadden, Colm Cavangh, Diarmuid O Connor, Paddy Durkin, Ryan McHugh, Andy Moran and a real personal favourite of mine in Jamie Clarke. Player of the decade for me would be between Bernard Brogan & Cluxton and I guess that you would have to give it to Cluxton Rory O'Carroll did enough pre 2016 to get full back. Dont think anyone else 2016 onwards dominated fb spot. McManus close to best forward in Ireland has to get in to ff line. If as you say big perfomances in big games are a factor then Philly must be close, possibly for McGlynn. For the same reason Aidan o'Shea drops out. Agree with your honourable mentions. Would add DC and Rock to that list. Yeah jeez cant believe that I forgot Rock. I found full back to be very hard to pick as dont feel there was any outstanding one so I essentially went with 3 corner backs. Philly had a good 2015 but thats about it in my opinion. I thought McGlynn was superb in the early part of the decade and think he deserves to be in. On McManus - I just feel like others deserve it more and if O Shea was dropped then it wouldn't be McManus to come in there. Like realistically you could name 15 Dublin players given that they have won 7 titles and not be too far off the mark (as much as it hurts to type that) |
|
|
|
Post by brucewayne on Dec 13, 2019 19:20:07 GMT
Cluxton
McMahon Cooper N. McGee
McCaffrey McCarthy Keegan
Fenton Gallagher
Flynn Kilkenny McHugh
McManus Murphy Donaghy
|
|
|
|
Post by Mickmack on Dec 13, 2019 23:56:04 GMT
No Darren Daly?
Seven All Ireland medals!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2019 8:29:38 GMT
Keegan and Michael Murphy would be the guaranteed non Dubs. You could make a good argument for Dublin players to make up the remaining 13 spots
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2019 8:34:39 GMT
A Kerry one and a national one Kerry: Kelly M Ó Sé O'Mahony Enright Murphy Crowley Morley Moran Maher O'Donoghue Gooch D Walsh Clifford Donaghy P Geaney National: Cluxton Cooper McGee Higgins McAffrey McCarthy Keegan Moran Fenton Flynn Murphy Kilkenny BBrogan McManus Moran Other than Kelly in goals, I would agree with that Kerry team. Killian Young the other main absentee. Half forward line may lack balance though! |
|
|
|
Post by The16thMan on Dec 15, 2019 0:06:05 GMT
My Kerry Team.
Kealy
Enright Marc Young
Tomás Crowley Murphy
Moran Maher
Jameso, Gooch, D.Walsh
Clifford Star Geaney.
Overall
Cluxton
Fitzsimons McGee Marc
Keegan McCarthy McCaffrey
Moran Fenton
A.O'Shea Gooch M.Murphy
McManus A.Moran B.Brogan
|
|
