|
Post by Annascaultilidie on Nov 20, 2018 14:39:37 GMT
Rough would definitely be yellow, would have to be more dangerous to be red I’d say but open to correction on that. We could argue all day over every call that way though. One persons view is different from the next. That’s kinda what makes sport what it is though. Nothing wrong with reasoned debate. On a side note, any word on any of our recent retirees heading down the media/punditry route? Think Donaghy would make a great analyst and be a hell of a lot better than some of the current panel on tv. no one would have had an issue with a yellow. not a black card in my opinion. How could it be a yellow? On viewing the video, it seems to my eye that: - At the very least it was an accidental coming together. - Perhaps it was an awkward coming together. - At worst it was a deliberate trip. I don't see any interpretation that suggests it was yellow. Looking at the video I would have said it was just about a free.
|
|
|
Post by goonised on Nov 20, 2018 15:10:15 GMT
Tis comical at this stage. Ciarrai Lar only contributer to reckon ref got the calls right.And the only contrubuter to have side on full on front on views of all the incidents. Some man in fairness Also chairing the BOS fan club. And another note he likes seeing big names sent off on the rare occasions they get to play with there clubs. Aren't we lucky Ciarrai Lar isn't a ref.😊😀😁😂
|
|
|
Post by ciarrailar on Nov 20, 2018 16:00:06 GMT
Tis comical at this stage. Ciarrai Lar only contributer to reckon ref got the calls right.And the only contrubuter to have side on full on front on views of all the incidents. Some man in fairness Also chairing the BOS fan club. And another note he likes seeing big names sent off on the rare occasions they get to play with there clubs. Aren't we lucky Ciarrai Lar isn't a ref.😊😀😁😂 You’re a mighty man for twisting things. I’ve more to be doing than replying to stupid allegations from you. Like I said, go get a rule book.
|
|
|
Post by goonised on Nov 20, 2018 16:01:58 GMT
Tis comical at this stage. Ciarrai Lar only contributer to reckon ref got the calls right.And the only contrubuter to have side on full on front on views of all the incidents. Some man in fairness Also chairing the BOS fan club. And another note he likes seeing big names sent off on the rare occasions they get to play with there clubs. Aren't we lucky Ciarrai Lar isn't a ref.😊😀😁😂 You’re a mighty man for twisting things. I’ve more to be doing than replying to stupid allegations from you. Like I said, go get a rule book. Twisting. ?
|
|
|
Post by ciarrailar on Nov 20, 2018 16:03:22 GMT
Rough would definitely be yellow, would have to be more dangerous to be red I’d say but open to correction on that. We could argue all day over every call that way though. One persons view is different from the next. That’s kinda what makes sport what it is though. Nothing wrong with reasoned debate. On a side note, any word on any of our recent retirees heading down the media/punditry route? Think Donaghy would make a great analyst and be a hell of a lot better than some of the current panel on tv. no one would have had an issue with a yellow. not a black card in my opinion. It’s a game of opinions! That’s what it’s all about. Many’s the heated argument had in a pub in front of a blazing fire with a pint in hand over this sort of stuff. ‘‘Tis where I’d rather be right now!
|
|
|
Post by ciarrailar on Nov 20, 2018 16:06:15 GMT
You’re a mighty man for twisting things. I’ve more to be doing than replying to stupid allegations from you. Like I said, go get a rule book. Twisting. ? Jesus goonised, there’d be a lot more going on if I was a ref. Running around after them would pose a slight problem lol lol For the life of me I’ll never fathom how anyone would do it. No end of abuse and never right no matter what. You seem to be well up on everything, maybe you should take it up?
|
|
|
Post by goonised on Nov 20, 2018 16:09:22 GMT
I only stated the rules on throw balls and free kicks. And you ask me to refer to rules book.
|
|
|
Post by classicfc on Nov 20, 2018 16:13:28 GMT
The referee wanted to be centre stage last Sunday and that is what transpired. How he was appointed ahead of Moriarty the senior referee from Keel is mind boggling? Paul Geaney honestly looked dumbfounded upon receiving a black card and Ciarrailar is trying to make it sound almost Sean Cavanaghesque.The referee also awarded at least 2 frees to an Annascaul attacker who used the oldest trick in the book, when the hand comes in pull it down as though u are being wrapped up and bring the defender to the ground underneath you. The referee claimed that the defender made an attempt to get the ball the 2nd time Tom Sullivan got caught high around the neck so no card was issued, ludicrous stuff.It is strange that there was a thread set up under the guise of the West Kerry Final when it is obvious Ciarrailar is just trying promote a below par refereeing performance
|
|
|
Post by allrounder on Nov 20, 2018 16:14:16 GMT
I'll leave this here to lighten the mood, did someone mention comedy!!!!
|
|
|
Post by goonised on Nov 20, 2018 16:30:47 GMT
The referee wanted to be centre stage last Sunday and that is what transpired. How he was appointed ahead of Moriarty the senior referee from Keel is mind boggling? Paul Geaney honestly looked dumbfounded upon receiving a black card and Ciarrailar is trying to make it sound almost Sean Cavanaghesque.The referee also awarded at least 2 frees to an Annascaul attacker who used the oldest trick in the book, when the hand comes in pull it down as though u are being wrapped up and bring the defender to the ground underneath you. The referee claimed that the defender made an attempt to get the ball the 2nd time Tom Sullivan got caught high around the neck so no card was issued, ludicrous stuff.It is strange that there was a thread set up under the guise of the West Kerry Final when it is obvious Ciarrailar is just trying promote a below par refereeing performance Correct which should have led to black card for annascaul attacker. I suppose there must be some directive to give inexperienced refs big games obviously with the view they might progress but this is novice shield stuff
|
|
|
Post by whacker on Nov 20, 2018 18:11:43 GMT
Tis comical at this stage. Ciarrai Lar only contributer to reckon ref got the calls right.And the only contrubuter to have side on full on front on views of all the incidents. Some man in fairness Also chairing the BOS fan club. And another note he likes seeing big names sent off on the rare occasions they get to play with there clubs. Aren't we lucky Ciarrai Lar isn't a ref.😊😀😁😂 Strange that he is billy se
|
|
|
Post by whacker on Nov 20, 2018 18:15:28 GMT
Tis comical at this stage. Ciarrai Lar only contributer to reckon ref got the calls right.And the only contrubuter to have side on full on front on views of all the incidents. Some man in fairness Also chairing the BOS fan club. And another note he likes seeing big names sent off on the rare occasions they get to play with there clubs. Aren't we lucky Ciarrai Lar isn't a ref.😊😀😁😂 You’re a mighty man for twisting things. I’ve more to be doing than replying to stupid allegations from you. Like I said, go get a rule book. Good man Billy , once you're happy with your performance
|
|
|
Post by goonised on Nov 20, 2018 18:44:18 GMT
Please Ciarrai Lar stop it. I'm sure the ref has reviewed game on YouTube and will be suitably embarrassed. Your not helpful his cause by suggesting county players be put off just the show balls
|
|
|
Post by westkerry18 on Nov 20, 2018 20:49:57 GMT
You’re a mighty man for twisting things. I’ve more to be doing than replying to stupid allegations from you. Like I said, go get a rule book. Good man Billy , once you're happy with your performance That’s very embarrassing getting caught out going under the name ciarrailar and bugging himself up as a ref (billy o she’s) if you look at his history on this it’s sll about refs and matches he was involved in
|
|